Purpose This study aimed to systematically review studies on the effect of peer tutoring on pediatric nursing education for nursing students and identify its contents and characteristics.
Methods A comprehensive search was conducted from November to December 2023 across databases including PubMed, Embase, CENTRAL, CINAHL, ProQuest, and others. We included both published and unpublished literature in English or Korean. Three reviewers independently screened and selected eligible studies that involved undergraduate nursing students participating in peer tutoring programs focused on pediatric nursing education. We analyzed quantitative outcomes related to learning effects and learner responses. The quality of the studies was assessed using the revised Cochrane risk-of-bias tool for randomized trials and the risk of bias assessment tool for non-randomized studies.
Results Five studies were reviewed, encompassing randomized controlled trials, a non-randomized controlled trial, a cohort study, and a before-after study. These interventions were conducted in school settings or pediatric clinical environments and featured different forms of peer teaching: horizontal, near-peer, and reciprocal. The tutor-to-tutee ratios ranged from 1:3 to 1:36.5. The educational content covered nursing care for major neonatal diseases, communication skills, medication administration, and resuscitation techniques. Significant improvements in cognitive knowledge and communication skills were observed among nursing students. However, there was noticeable variability in the design and reporting of the studies.
Conclusion Peer tutoring programs can effectively enhance pediatric nursing education by improving nursing students’ knowledge and skills. For future meta-analyses, more studies in this field reported according to reporting guidelines are needed.
Purpose This study aimed to explore nursing students' experiences of neonatal nursing simulations using peer tutoring.
Methods In this qualitative content analysis study, data were collected using a narrative survey and focus group interviews with 27 third-year nursing students and six fourth-year nursing students from April to May 2022. Content analysis of the collected data was conducted.
Results Four categories—"stabilizing emotionally through each other", "advancing together", "difficulties in relationships", and "hoping to continue"—and nine sub-categories were extracted. The sub-categories "reduced burden" and "gaining confidence" were grouped into the first category, "stabilizing emotionally through each other". The sub-categories "being motivated to learn," "increased learning ability", and "preparation as a process" were grouped under "advancing together", and "attitudes affecting study environment" and "depending on help" were grouped into the third category of "difficulties in relationships". The fourth category of "hoping to continue" had "wanting to supplement for development" and "wanting to participate in different roles" as sub-categories.
Conclusion Based on the results of this study, we expect pediatric nursing practicum education to improve through the active use of neonatal nursing simulation education incorporating peer tutoring.
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
Tutoring experiences of a high-risk newborn care simulation among nurse tutors and nursing student tutees in South Korea: a qualitative study Hyun Young Koo, Bo Ryeong Lee, Hyeran An Child Health Nursing Research.2025; 31(1): 40. CrossRef
Child Nursing Simulation Scenario Content Analysis: A Directed Qualitative Content Analysis Eun Joo Kim, Kyung Mi Cho, Sung Sook Song Clinical Simulation in Nursing.2024; 87: 101488. CrossRef
Effects of peer tutoring-based simulation education on caring for children with respiratory infections among nursing students: A mixed-methods study Hyun Young Koo, Bo Ryeong Lee Heliyon.2024; 10(16): e36014. CrossRef
The effect of peer tutoring on pediatric nursing education: a systematic review Hyun Young Koo, Hyeran An, Bo Ryeong Lee Child Health Nursing Research.2024; 30(4): 215. CrossRef
PURPOSE This study was done to provide basic data for education of elementary school students on life-respect and peer bullying prevention. METHODS Participants were 5th and 6th grade elementary school students. Data from the questionnaires of 218 participants were analyzed. RESULTS 1) The mean score for degree of life-respect was 4.23 (+/-0.38). The types of peer bullying were 'defenders of victims' (3.19+/-0.93), 'bullies' (2.04+/-0.72), 'victims' (1.91+/-0.84), 'bystanders' (1.79+/-0.80), and 'bully-followers' (1.66+/-0.60). 2) There was a significant difference in the degree of life-respect according to gender (t=-2.410, p=.017). Likewise, in the degree of peer bullying, among the type of 'bullies' there were significant differences according to grade (t=-2.285, p=.004), and gender (t=3.191, p=.002). Also, among the types of 'bully-followers' there were significant differences according to gender (t=2.053, p=.041), and having a religion or not (t=3.319, p=.001). 3) There was a significant correlation between life-respect and types of peer bullying. CONCLUSION The results of this study provide helps for more effective provision of educational programs regarding life-respect and peer bullying.
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
Systematic Review of Meaning-centered Interventions for Adolescents Young Sook Lim, Kyung A Kang Child Health Nursing Research.2018; 24(3): 263. CrossRef
A Systematic Review of Forest Therapy Programs for Elementary School Students Min Kyung Song, Kyung-Sook Bang Child Health Nursing Research.2017; 23(3): 300. CrossRef
Relationship between Elementary School Students’ Bullying Experience and Bioethics Mi Young Moon Journal of the Korean Society of School Health.2015; 28(2): 127. CrossRef